Featured Article: “One of the World’s Oldest Science Experiments Comes Up From the Dirt” by Cara Giaimo
Michigan State University is home to the Beal seed viability experiment. The project, which has gone on for 142 years, is an attempt to figure out how long seeds can lie dormant in the soil without losing their ability to germinate.
In this lesson, you will learn about the origins of the experiment, how it has evolved over time and what it can teach us today.
Look closely at the image presented with this lesson and consider these three questions:
■ What is going on in this picture?
■ What do you see that makes you say that?
■ What more can you find?
Now read the first two paragraphs of the featured article.
On Thursday morning, several hours before sunrise, Marjorie Weber arrived at a rendezvous spot on the campus of Michigan State University. Three of the school’s other plant scientists were already there, waiting in dribbling snow. As they stood around blowing on their hands, the fifth member of their crew, Frank Telewski, “emerged from the darkness with a shovel slung over his shoulder,” Dr. Weber said.
With everyone else crowded around, Dr. Telewski, the group’s leader, pulled out a copy of a map from 1931, drawn like an architectural blueprint. It would guide them to a botanist’s version of buried treasure: a bottle filled with sand and a bunch of really old seeds.
■ How does the writer pull you into the story?
■ What questions did you have as you started to read the piece?
■ Based on the image presented here, and the first two paragraphs of the article, what do you think the group of people might be gathering to do? What makes you think that?
Questions for Writing and Discussion
Read the featured article below, then answer the following questions:
1. Describe the Beal seed viability experiment in your own words. What is its purpose and how is the experiment conducted?
2. How have advancements in technology expanded the kind of research and knowledge that scientists are able to gain from the experiment?
3. What question was William James Beal, a botanist at Michigan State, trying to answer when he started the experiment? What purpose did it most likely serve during that time period? What questions can the experiment answer now?
4. What are the “cloaked, secretive” elements of the digs, and why are they necessary, both now and when the experiment first began?
5. What are scientists able to learn about a seed, beyond if it sprouted or not, and what implications does that knowledge have? What experiments will this year’s team put these seeds through, and what do they hope to learn?
One of the World’s Oldest Science Experiments Comes Up From the Dirt
By Cara Giaimo
April 21, 2021
The New York Times
On April 15, hours before sunrise, Marjorie Weber arrived at a rendezvous spot on the campus of Michigan State University. Three of the school’s other plant scientists were already there, waiting in dribbling snow. As they stood around blowing on their hands, the fifth member of their crew, Frank Telewski, “emerged from the darkness with a shovel slung over his shoulder,” Weber said.
With everyone else crowded around, Telewski, the group’s leader, pulled out a copy of a map, drawn like an architectural blueprint. It would guide them to a botanist’s version of buried treasure: a bottle filled with sand and a bunch of really old seeds.
Weber and her colleagues are the latest custodians of the Beal seed viability experiment: a multicentury attempt to figure out how long seeds can lie dormant in the soil without losing their ability to germinate. Every 20 years, the experiment’s caretakers creep out to a secret location under cover of night, dig up a bottle, scatter its seeds over a tray of sterile soil and see which ones grow.
It is one of the world’s longest-running experiments, having already gone on for 142 years. And the botanists in East Lansing hope that it will last for at least another 80.
What started out as a straightforward attempt to measure seed persistence has grown into a more interesting experiment as the decades pass. With technology improving and knowledge increasing, the keepers of the cache can do more than just count each bottle’s successful sprouts. They can look inside seeds to see how they tick, begin to determine what accounts for longevity — and even, in some cases, get species that seemed done for to spring up again. Lessons from their work could help with everything from restoring damaged ecosystems to storing crop seeds for the long term.
But first, they had to find where to dig.
A Long Row to Hoe
The bottle the team was looking for contains more than 1,000 seeds: 50 each of 21 different species, from black mustard to white clover to redroot amaranth.
In 1879, William James Beal, a botanist at Michigan State, filled 20 such bottles and buried them in a row somewhere on campus. He figured he — and later, his successors — could dig one up every five years and plant the preserved seeds inside.
When seeds are shed by their parents, they do not always grow right away. Under any given patch of land, there is a constellation of sleeping seeds “biding their time,” Weber said. Often, they lie dormant — for a season, a few years or even longer — until they get the right set of cues to sprout.
This plant reserve is known as the seed bank. By experimentally re-creating it, Beal hoped to better understand how long plants could last in the soil and what prompts them to grow. He was likely trying to help local farmers — frustrated by endless weeding and wondering how long it would take “before they might have some hope of seeing a decline in the seed bank and their workload going down,” Telewski said.
For the first few rounds of the experiment, a number of species flourished, with seeds growing readily after 10, 15 or 20 years. As the decades passed, most dropped off one by one. Only one reliable sprouter is left: Verbascum blattaria, a splay-leaved, yellow-flowered herb. Nearly half the Verbascum seeds from 2000’s bottle bloomed, even though they had been in stasis underground for more than a century.
Today, farmers do not really need the kind of help with weeds that motivated Beal to bury his bottles. But plant scientists have become invested in the question of which seeds last and how for other reasons.
The soil seed banks underlying different habitats are “great unknowns” in restoration ecology as experts try to promote native species while fending off invasive ones, said Lars Brudvig, an assistant professor at Michigan State and another member of the Beal seed experiment team. In some cases, seeds of endangered or long-lost plants may even be hiding out in the soil.
Other researchers working on questions of longevity and germination might save seeds in climate-controlled environments or study very old ones that they happen to find. But Beal’s is the longest-running seed experiment to mix natural conditions with carefully recorded data, said Carol Baskin, a professor of plant and soil sciences at the University of Kentucky who has used its results in her work.
“I think professor Beal’s got the top experiment here,” Baskin said. “I wish he’d have buried more bottles.”
Armed with shovels, gloves and headlamps, the team followed their map to the dig site. The vibe was “very piratey,” Weber said. Telewski set to digging a neat, squared-off hole.
But as they carved deeper and wider, there were no bottles to be found. “The birds were starting to chirp,” Weber said, and the sun threatened to blow their cover. “Morale was low.”
When Beal first buried the seed bottles, he planned to have one dug up every five years and for the experiment to last a century. But as time passed, those in charge extended the span between digs to 10 years, then 20. Two have been slightly delayed: 1919’s was moved to the spring of 1920 — which Telewski suspects may have been related to the 1918 flu; and 2020’s was moved to this year because of COVID-19-related campus shutdowns.
To avoid losing the thread across these decades, a sort of ministry of seed-keepers has developed at Michigan State, with each generation of botanists passing the torch to younger colleagues.
Telewski — a professor of plant biology at the university and the seventh person in charge of the experiment — dug up his first seed bottle in 2000 with his predecessor, Jan Zeevaart, who died in 2009. A couple of years ago, mulling his own mortality, he gave a copy of the map to David Lowry, an associate professor of plant biology who had expressed interest in joining up.
Just a couple of months later, Telewski had a stroke. While he has since recovered, “it just showed me how delicate it is to hand these things off while keeping them secret,” Lowry said. Soon after, Telewski invited Weber, who is an assistant professor at the university, and Brudvig to get involved as well.
Over the years, what were purely practical decisions by Beal have developed a patina of mystique. Beal excavated each new bottle under cover of darkness — not to be dramatic but simply to protect the other bottled seeds from sunlight, which might cause them to germinate before their time, Telewski said. (The team uses green bulbs in their headlamps for the same reason.)
The paper map was drawn after the landmarks that originally indicated the bottles’ location were moved. And the stealth is newly necessary because the older the experiment gets, the more interest it draws, he said.
These “cloaked, secretive” elements are now part of the experiment’s charm, Weber said. But it is camaraderie and a desire to see the experiment through that keeps things going. The night before the dig, Telewski sent a pump-up email to the group. It included his own five-verse reimagining of Simon & Garfunkel’s “The Sound of Silence.” A sample lyric: “Hello bottles my old friends / I’ve come to dig you up again.”
Hearing about the experiment before he came to Michigan State, “I could imagine druids going out in the night and digging this thing up,” said Lowry. “Now that I know who’s involved, it’s like, ‘Hey, it’s just Frank.’”
Old Seeds, New Tricks
A little past 6 a.m., with daylight creeping up, Lowry realized they had been reading the map wrong. A recalibration set them digging about 2 feet west.
After some false alarms — tree roots, a rock — Weber, now digging with her hands, hit something smooth. Slowly, she eased the bottle out of the ground as her fellow initiates cheered. “It kind of felt like delivering a baby or finding a really important treasure,” she said. “There was a huge sense of relief.”
This year, for the first time, the dug-up seeds did not go straight to the growth chamber. Instead, another member of the team, Margaret Fleming, a postdoctoral researcher, brought them to a cold room, where she removed some seeds of Setaria glauca — a species of millet, which has not sprouted in the experiment since 1914 — for genetic analysis.
Planting a seed is like asking it a yes or no question. The seed either sprouts or it does not. But often a seed that does not grow is not fully dead. Examining its DNA and RNA lets scientists interrogate it much further. They can find out whether its machinery has degraded or persisted, how damaged the genetic material is, and what processes may still be possible even if germination is not, Fleming said.
Bringing in a new generation of stewards is an opportunity to rethink the experiment’s possibilities. When these seeds were buried, “we didn’t even know what DNA was,” Telewski said. Multiple generations in, “very fundamental questions that are going to really help us understand seed dormancy and seed viability can now begin to be addressed.”
The stakes of these questions are also changing. Recent decades have seen a growing number of seed storage projects, including Indigenous food sovereignty efforts and doomsday prevention crop seed vaults. A better understanding of what allows specific seeds to stay functional while dormant as well as what causes them to sprout could help with this work.
After the rest of the seeds are sown and watered, the team will keep watch, expecting the 142-year-old Verbascum seeds to put forth tender green shoots.
Then they will try some more tricks based on discoveries from the field of plant ecology. For starters, they will put the whole bed of soil through a cold treatment to simulate a second winter — a move that, in the 2000 batch, yielded a single seedling of a mallow species, Malva pusilla.
The team will also try something new: exposing the seeds to smoke. This may prompt germination in some plants that are known to thrive after wildfires, such as Erechtites hieraciifolius, or fireweed, which has never once sprouted during the experiment.
The team is eager for the results of these growth tests, which should come in the next couple of weeks.
But they also are looking forward to “19 years from now,” Brudvig said, “when we’re going to be seeking out the young colleagues in the department and saying ‘Psst, hey, can I show you a map?’”